Skip to content

Article

Merit cycle: together with or separate from the performance cycle?

The Merit Cycle and the Performance Cycle play essential roles in assessing, developing and recognizing employees, but it is important to understand how they differ and to weigh the pros and cons of running these cycles together or separately.

  • Fernanda Markiewicz

Published Dec 27, 2023

The Merit Cycle and the Performance Cycle play essential roles in assessing, developing and recognizing employees, but it is important to understand how they differ and to weigh the pros and cons of running these cycles together or separately.

Since we see many leaders today with questions about the best option for their business, we prepared an article that shows some of the existing strategies so you can reflect on which path is ideal for your company.

Here we bring the results of a survey run by Zivo in December 2023, which shows how the market currently stands on this choice, the pros and cons of each position, and comments from people leaders about the methodology they use in their companies.

In the survey section, we also dig into how often merit cycles are run and which months are most often chosen, and how all these choices (together, separate, when, how often) relate to the size of the participating companies.

First, what is the difference between the merit cycle and the performance cycle?

The Performance Cycle is an assessment of employees' performance over time, aimed at specific goals, regular feedback and continuous improvement, looking at the present and the future.

The Merit Cycle, meanwhile, is a process that focuses on reviewing and making decisions about rewards, promotions and recognition of employees based not only on their past performance but also on tenure, alignment with culture, position in the salary range, among other factors.

What is the current market picture on running the cycles together or separately?

We ran a survey with more than 228 companies, predominantly from São Paulo, to understand what the market preference has been on running Merit and Performance Cycles together or separately, and to understand how often and in which months these cycles were run.

The companies had different sizes and can be split into 4 groups:

  • 25% with 0 - 250 employees
  • 25% with 251 - 750 employees
  • 25% with 751 - 5,000 employees
  • 25% with more than 5,000 employees

How many merit cycles do these companies run per year?

First, we looked at how often merit cycles happen at the responding companies and whether this frequency was related to their size, and the results were as follows:

  • Once a year: 31.4%
  • Twice a year: 28.6%
  • Three times a year: 20.0%
  • Four times a year: 4.3%
  • Undefined (no specific date, happens on a recurring basis): 14.3%
  • Constant: 1.4%

In which months do companies usually run merit cycles

  • At companies that run cycles once a year: April is the most chosen month.
  • At companies that run cycles twice a year: April and October are the most frequent months (usually they are 6 months apart).
  • At companies that run cycles three times a year: March, July and November are the most common.

The data collected showed no clear pattern demonstrating a correlation between the choice of months or the frequency of the merit cycle and company size.

Performance cycle and merit cycle: together or separate?

On running Merit and Performance Cycles together or separately, the results showed almost a tie, with two groups of very similar size and opposing positions. While 60% choose to run the cycles together, 40% of companies said they choose to separate the merit and performance cycles.

How this varies by size

Curious to understand whether this trend varied with company size, we dug into that variable and found that yes, it affects this choice. In general, smaller companies (up to 250 employees) are more likely to run the merit cycle together with the performance cycle (75%), while larger companies are more mixed between running them together and separately, with a slightly greater lean toward running them separately (56% vs. 44%).

Arguments for and against running the cycles together

Given these statistics, it is important to understand the pros and cons of each choice so you can make your own decision about what makes the most sense for your company right now. Below we present some arguments to reflect on.

Arguments against running the cycles together

  • Less Focus on Continuous Improvement: Integrating the cycles can reduce the focus on ongoing performance management, since the emphasis may lean toward past assessments, limiting guidance for continuous improvement.

  • Possible Influence of Recent Performance: Reward decisions may be more influenced by the most recent performance, ignoring achievements across the year and not reflecting overall performance.

Arguments for running the cycles together

  • Alignment of Goals and Recognition: By integrating the cycles, it is possible to better align individual performance goals with the rewards and recognition granted, strengthening the direct link between performance and recognition.

  • Simpler Processes: Integrating the cycles can simplify administrative and communication processes for employees and managers, since it reduces the need to manage multiple workflows.

  • Holistic Approach: A combined approach can offer a more holistic view of employee performance across the year, helping identify patterns and manage rewards more strategically.

What people leaders using each methodology say

We invited some leaders from the Zivo CHROs in Tech Community (a group made up of the most influential leaders in tech in Brazil, who meet regularly to discuss people best practices) to comment on why they made their choices and how they run this process internally.

Company with separate cycles

"Here it has been separate from the start because we believe the process should be 100% focused on development, and by separating the two conversations we manage (we try) to reduce some important biases that can happen. Now we are piloting the agile model, with monthly check-ins. By doing it monthly, the employee's development process is continuous, dynamic and more adaptable (which matters at the pace of the company). Merit and promotion decisions are made at the end of the quarter with 3 data points (monthly pulses), together with a people committee with stakeholders, peers and leaders, considering the pulse results, plus pre-established eligibility criteria." Sofia Any Kaloustian, People Manager at Sami

Company with joint cycles

Ottilia Duarte, who leads Engagement, Culture and Compensation at Pravaler, commented on some interesting practices they have there to run the cycles together while reducing bias:

"Here at Pravaler it is together, but we build a merit matrix that takes into account: position in the range, the last two years of performance, tenure, time since last promotion, time in the role, etc. This matrix gives us a priority level of 1, 2 and 3. (…) Here, after we started using it, indicators such as post-promotion turnover, using the budget without going over, etc. improved a lot!"

Conclusion

Ultimately, both the Merit Cycle and the Performance Cycle play crucial roles in human resources management. The decision to run them together or separately should be weighed against the company's specific needs, context and organizational culture. While the joint approach can simplify processes, running them separately can provide more refined management of individual performance. Understanding the differences between the two is crucial to strategically steering human resources policy toward the organization's long-term success and the continuous growth of its employees.

Would you like Zivo's help to run merit cycles in a fairer, simpler way? Click here to learn more about our solutions.

Book a conversation with an
AI-native HR Transformation Specialist