
Strategy
How does remote work affect your compensation strategy?
Please note that this blog post was originally written in English and translated into Portuguese by the Zivo team
Published Dec 14, 2022
Please note that this blog post was originally written in English and translated into Portuguese by the Zivo team
Over the last ±2 years we have seen companies (forced to) quickly adopt remote work, and in doing so, step into previously unknown territory: how to hire and onboard remotely, how to activate culture without any physical presence, how to assess performance and how to handle total compensation are just a few examples of the people strategy elements companies have had to redesign.
But the changes of the past few years were also very visible on the personal side: people moving away from high-cost cities, some working while traveling through several countries, and even the elimination of the notion of a pre-defined work schedule, for better or worse. In fact, jobs with some remote component receive at least 2x more applications than office-based jobs (LinkedIn Talent Connect 2022).
With all these changes, it became clear that companies need to set their position on remote work and its compensation, and communicate it clearly to their teams. But what is the right way? Since compensation is, in a way, a market force, there is no universal right / wrong answer. Companies need to find what works best for them (and their teams) specifically.
Although several different approaches have emerged on this topic, the three most common trends remain:
- Locally competitive pay
- Geographic tiers
- Location-agnostic pay
Let's now explore the pros and cons of each:
Locally competitive pay
This is probably the most traditional approach, in which salary ranges are set based on geographic location and the same role will be paid differently depending on where a person is based.
Some of the advantages of locally competitive pay are that it makes it easy to explain to team members exactly how salary ranges are set, which can usually be backed by compensation surveys, for which location-based data is significantly more abundant than for other alternatives. Another advantage is that this type of strategy tends to result in lower spending, since you would be paying the standard for each specific location (and, as a result, avoiding overpaying).
On the other hand, this strategy is not without drawbacks: historically, it has been seen as unfair, because people who deliver the same or better results in the same role may receive lower pay than others merely because of their geographic location.
When thinking about how this applies to companies that work remotely, it is important to first look at the demographics and hiring strategy of the teams: a remote company with few or no people working together in the same geographic location may find this approach unsuitable and labor-intensive, while it can be an excellent option for companies with medium to large teams spread across a few locations.
Geographic tier pay
This pay approach has become increasingly popular over the last two years. Basically, locations that pay similarly are mapped and grouped into tiers. The logic works for tiers of cities, states or countries.
Some of the advantages of this approach are that it lets companies differentiate between high and low labor-cost locations without restricting them to hiring in one specific place (and, as a result, increasing their potential talent pool). In addition, this type of pay requires less administrative work than locally competitive pay, while for the most part still avoiding unnecessary overpaying in a given market. These benefits have made it an attractive model for companies that are growing their teams aggressively across several locations.
On the flip side, setting the exact salary range for the different tiers is not always super simple and can be hard to explain to team members. GitLab, for example, used to rely on the income index to represent local market rates, but later evolved to incorporate more data because the income index alone did not offer a strong enough correlation. Although geographic tiers are a balanced pay approach, they are mostly useful for defining salary ranges, and harder to implement when it comes to benefits.
For both locally competitive models and geographic tiers, the question is what to do if someone moves from a high labor-cost market to a low labor-cost one. For this challenge, companies have taken one of three positions:
- Adjust pay to match the new market (which is sometimes both culturally and legally challenging)
- Keep the pay level unchanged, but freeze any future raises until the new location catches up with the individual's pay
- Ignore the relocation entirely.
Location-agnostic pay
This strategy holds that where you work should not influence how much you are paid. This means people in the same role are paid within the same band, regardless of their location. Although still implemented by a limited number of companies, this type of pay strategy has gained traction in the high-tech sector, with companies such as Reddit and Basecamp.
Location-agnostic pay is often applied in two different ways: nationally, or worldwide (often referred to as IPS: International pay structures).
Some of the advantages of this pay model are that it lets companies set very competitive salaries, removes a large part of the pay negotiation from the hiring process, requires a low administrative load to maintain and makes pay transparency easy.
On the other hand, location-agnostic pay tends to be more expensive: since it is unlikely that you would set the range at the lowest common denominator (if you want to stay competitive in other markets), you are likely overpaying in some areas. This model encourages teams to move away from central cities to lower-cost ones, and it is not the friendliest model for companies with a hybrid remote / on-site model. It is also said to create golden handcuff scenarios for people, who are unlikely to land equally paid jobs in low labor-cost cities and therefore stay at companies purely out of salary. In addition, as with geographic tiers, location-agnostic pay does not account for differences in legally required benefits or time-off policies based on your home address or location.
For all the reasons above, this model is noticeably more popular among remote companies, those with a large number of digital nomads in their headcount.
How to decide what is right for your company:
Although there is no universal right answer when it comes to setting your pay strategy, it is important to ask yourself a few questions that can help you better determine which model is right for your company / team:
- What kind of company do you want to be?
- How does your pay strategy align with your values?
- What is your target talent base and how is it distributed?
- How do you expect your workforce to evolve in the coming years?
- How much can you afford to pay?
The answers to some of these questions may not be entirely simple. For example, your team may be made up of both salaried employees and PJ (independent contractor) / freelancers. In those cases, you will have to make more complex decisions, such as whether to match employee benefits with additional pay for contractors / PJ to bring full equity to the team. Such decisions have financial and potentially legal implications, but you will have to answer these questions and make consistent decisions to find your right pay strategy.
It is also very important to understand how this element (compensation) of your people strategy aligns with the rest of your employee value proposition: remember that compensation, while super important, is only one element that attracts and retains your talent, and it is not the only thing that matters. Far from it: people join and stay at companies for many other, more intangible rewards, such as recognition, career development opportunities, pride in the work they do and a sense of inclusion. So make sure that whatever your pay strategy is, it is aligned and consistent with the rest of your employee experience, to build an attractive and competitive environment for your talent base.