
Article
Incentive Is Strategy: Why the Supreme Court decision on Stock Options puts the CHRO at the decision table.
The Supreme Court decision on Stock Options turns incentives into a competitive advantage and positions the CHRO as a key piece of corporate strategy.
Published Dec 4, 2025
Before joining the Zivo team, I carried a quiet conviction, almost a personal belief about the corporate world: Long-Term Incentives (LTI) have always been underused. Too often, I saw LTI treated as just a line in the total compensation package, a "golden handcuff" for retention or a simple financial upside.
But my view was always broader. I believed, and today, working side by side with founders and executives at many companies, I can confirm, that LTI is perhaps the purest alignment mechanism that exists in modern capitalism and in the new economy. It isn't only there to pay well; it is there to turn executives into owners. More than that: it motivates leaders and gives them the clarity they need to execute, with precision, the strategy the Board of Directors and shareholders want.
When we design an effective plan, the People function stops being an operational cost center and takes a seat as decisive as that of a Chief Revenue Officer or a CFO. If Sales brings in the revenue and Finance optimizes capital, HR, through smart incentives, shapes the behavior that creates the company's future value. Incentive is strategy. And now, with the recent Supreme Court decision (STF), that strategy has gained an unprecedented competitive advantage in Brazil.
The watershed: Theme 1,226 and the Commercial Nature
In recent weeks, Brazil's compensation and governance market has breathed a sigh of relief. In ruling on ARE 1,436,593, the Supreme Court (STF) reinforced the Superior Court of Justice's (STJ) understanding (Theme 1,226) and established that Stock Options have a commercial nature, not a salary nature, as long as certain criteria are met.
For CEOs, CFOs and CHROs, this is not just a legal detail; it is a transformative change in capital efficiency and talent attraction.
In practice, this decisively strengthens the thesis that labor and social security charges (such as INSS and FGTS) do not apply to the grant or exercise of the options. The executive pays no income tax when buying the share (exercise), only when selling it and realizing the profit (capital gain).
The impact on the corporate landscape
This decision unlocks immediate value on three main fronts:
- Competing for Elite Talent: Startups and technology companies have always used equity as a bargaining chip. With the legal certainty now established by the STF, traditional companies can enter this game more aggressively. The compensation package becomes more elastic and has greater potential to multiply, without burdening the company's current cash.
- Cash and Tax Efficiency: For the CFO, the Stock Option plan becomes a vital cash preservation instrument. By shifting the reward to the future and tying it to the company's success, you fund growth with growth itself. Even considering the trade-off of the expense not being deductible for IRPJ/CSLL (corporate income taxes), a logical consequence of the commercial nature, the savings from the exemption from labor charges can make the final equation extremely favorable.
- A Real "Owner" Culture: When tax is only paid on the final sale, the executive is encouraged to hold the share, aligning their time horizon with the shareholder's. The focus moves away from the short term and aims at the longevity of the business.
The Catch: Where Strategy Meets Technique
Despite the euphoria, caution is needed. The STF decision is not a "blank check." For a plan to be considered commercial (and enjoy this tax efficiency), it has to be technically defensible and rigorously documented. This is where the "art" of designing compensation programs meets legal science. I confess this is one of the parts that fascinates me most, and where we at Zivo can do the most to help companies find a consistent and sound path.
To secure the thesis, your company needs to respect the triad of commercial nature:
- Voluntariness: Joining the plan must be a clear choice by the employee, never an imposition tied to the employment contract.
- Onerousness: The executive must pay for the share. It can't be free. The Strike Price (exercise price) must be fair and close to market value. This brings a new perspective, since a very common market practice was an aggressive discount on the strike price to make the gain easier. Under the new understanding, excessive discounts can undermine the investment character and invite labor risk.
- Risk: This is the key point. The executive has to bear the risk of market variation. If the share falls below the exercise price, the option goes underwater and they receive nothing. To shield this thesis (especially while the STJ is still refining its final position on social security incidence, Controversy 741), it may be worth considering the use of Lock-ups, a deep review of contracts and an update of internal communication, making clear that the executive is exposed to volatility. This is where the Stock Option plan (SOP) differs sharply from other programs such as Restricted Stock Units (RSUs), where the gain is almost guaranteed. In an SOP, the risk is real and binary. This is where we truly land the "skin in the game."
And beyond the technical shielding, one of the questions we hear most from executives and founders is: 'How much should I offer?' or 'How much is my Stock Option worth today?'. Our answer is clear: forget face value and focus on appreciation potential.
Stock Options are not meant to supplement monthly income or generate immediate liquidity; they are the sale of a future promise, they complement the long-term package and retain key people. That is why, at Zivo, we take building a consistent financial narrative with a well-designed valuation seriously. It isn't just about 'selling a dream', but about methodically structuring the upside potential so it becomes the central pillar of the Employee Value Proposition (EVP). The value lies beyond what the company is today, in the growth thesis the executive will help build.
The CHRO's New Role
Back to my initial thesis: HR is strategy. In this new scenario, more than ever, the CHRO has the chance to go to the CEO with a proposal that goes beyond the "salary survey."
The conversation is now about value architecture. It is about the company's long term. It is about saying: "We can attract the market's elite by inviting them to be partners in our ambition. By offering a vehicle for building real wealth, we shift the mindset from employee to owner." The focus is no longer just monthly pay but multiplying the company's value, making sure the executive works with the same long-term vision the CEO and the Board have.
At Zivo, we see this happening every day. LTI stopped being a "bonus" and became the engine of corporate governance. The STF decision only confirmed what we already knew: when everyone wins from the company's appreciation, growth stops being a goal and becomes an inevitable consequence.
The question left for your Board: is your incentive plan designed to take advantage of this new era, or does it still carry the legal fragilities of the past?