
Bonus
Should my company pay bonuses even before turning a profit?
It depends… There are several ways to look at bonus systems, but few contexts are as challenging as the one tech companies live in, where there is good performance and leveraged growth, but still not enough for steady profit generation. Starting with the concept…
Published Oct 10, 2022
It depends…
There are many ways to look at bonus systems, but few contexts are as challenging as the one technology companies live in, where there is good performance and leveraged growth, but not yet enough for steady profit.
Starting with the concept, what is a bonus?
The bonus, technically called PLR (Participação nos Lucros e Resultados, profit and results sharing) or, at some companies, PPR (Programa de Participação de Resultados, results sharing program), is an incentive that seeks to align the company's short-term priorities (usually 1 year) with employees' financial goals. In other words, if the company hits certain business metrics (revenue, profit, number of customers, NPS, etc.), it is willing to pay an additional reward to the employees who made that happen during the year.
One of the most culturally relevant points is that it is an additional payment on top of what employees already receive monthly in salary. It is worth remembering that:
| Pays for: | Used for: | |
|---|---|---|
| Salary | Day-to-day work, as described in the job description: Writing code, building products, producing reports, customer service, etc. | Sustaining the employee's lifestyle, paying the month's bills (rent, food, leisure, etc.) |
| Bonus | Results achieved at or above what the business expected, through the work done. | Buying things out of reach of the monthly income (a TV, a car, etc.), building wealth (emergency fund, investments, etc.) |
In short, people receive salary for doing their job, and they receive a bonus for the results their work achieved.
Why does it matter?
This incentive has long been part of companies' compensation packages for 2 main reasons:
Financial incentive: as mentioned above, employees look at company results in a more critical and ambitious way when there is a meaningful financial incentive for it. Without one, the person gets the same salary every month whether the company is doing well or badly.
Market competitiveness: Because most companies use this incentive, those that do not would be paying below the average of the others, and that can be a big problem for attracting and retaining talent.
Beyond the points above, culturally, Brazil is a country that places a lot of value on results-sharing programs (PPR and PLR), so if you do not have one, it will be something employees always bring up as a pain point.
How do I know when to implement one at my company?
This question should be answered by examining the 2 points raised earlier in the context of your company:
- Does the company already have effective incentives (financial or not) for achieving results above expectations?
- Does your company have a clear compensation advantage (in salary, benefits or equity) that is competitive enough against the companies competing for your talent?
If the answer to both questions is yes, you do not need to worry right now about adding another incentive. If not, and if you see both points as concerning and relevant for your company, we recommend starting conversations with your senior leadership and board about implementing a bonus.
One of the main problems with incentive strategy is that incentives are designed by HR, accepted by leadership (sometimes with their own benefit in mind, as eligible participants), and the board is rarely 100% convinced and aligned on their need and impact.
That is why we recommend that the proposal presentation include:
- A compensation strategy where the bonus is an important pillar within people's total package.
- A market analysis covering a broad group of competing companies.
- Market data showing that people's current package lags behind competitors.
- Turnover data where compensation is a reason people give when leaving the company
- Data on rejected offers because the compensation package was not compatible with the candidate's current one, or compared with another offer the person decided to accept
- Simulations of total amounts payable under different company result scenarios, emphasizing the most pessimistic and most optimistic ones.
- Example:
- “If the company does not reach the minimum value X, no bonus is paid” “If the company achieves extraordinary results Y, we should pay X% of the year's revenue in bonuses”
- Example:
I want to implement one. How do I design it?
It is a process whose complexity depends entirely on your company's cultural characteristics.
It can be something simple, where everyone gets a proportionally “similar” amount, or it can be a complex process where each person earns very different amounts depending on their individual contribution to overall results.
Let's split the design process into 4 parts:
- Who gets it? Eligibility
- How much do they get? Amounts
- How is it calculated? Calculation logic
- When is it paid? Payment frequency
Eligibility
There are 2 paths here: you can choose the path where all employees in the company are eligible, with amounts matching their levels within the company, or only leaders and critical/strategic positions are eligible.
All CLT employees are eligible: this option makes it easier to get union approval as a results-sharing program (PPR/PLR), so the payment is made under a line item exempt from labor charges (INSS, FGTS, Sistema S, 13th salary and vacation). It also allows a company-wide program with more transparency and engagement from everyone.
Only leaders and critical/strategic positions are eligible: this option lets you concentrate the incentive on the company's key people, which also makes it easier to set and track goals. Because it does not cover 100% of the people at the company, it is highly unlikely to be approved as a PPR or to get the charge exemption on payment.
Depending on the ratio of leaders to non-leaders, along with the proposed amounts, there are scenarios where extending the program to all employees can cost the same as the labor charges under the second option, so it is worth reviewing whether this separation pays off.
Amounts
Start by classifying your company's roles and/or people into “comparable” groups of scope and complexity. You can call these groups levels or “grades”, as they are commonly called in the compensation world
For each of these levels, we will define the target bonus amount, which is what should be paid to the person if they reach 100% of the agreed results.
To assign these amounts, having a quantitative market survey of bonus values on hand is crucial! With it you will see which levels are comparable to those in your organization and understand an average payout for that level according to the competitiveness strategy you want.
If you do not have access to those values but do trust market salary data, you can set bonus values based on their ratio to base salary
Example: For engineering managers, the average market value is R$ 20,000 monthly salary.
The annual base salary (SBA) is calculated by multiplying by 13.33 (12 salaries + 13th + ⅓ vacation bonus), so in this case the SBA for this position is R$ 266,600.
If we want the ratio of these 2 components (SBA and bonus) within our company to be 80% / 20%, we get the bonus value of XXX using a simple rule of three.
(266,600 / 80%) * 20% = 66,650
We can define this value as a rounded gross amount, e.g., R$ 67,000, or express it as a number of salaries: 66,650/20,000 = 3.33, rounding to 3.5 or to 3 salaries depending on the competitiveness you want.
This process should be done for every level for which we want to calculate the bonus, to get a complete table.
Calculation logic
There are countless methodologies to guide the definition of the bonus calculation logic. Here are the most common in the market:
100% company results: This is the program that is simplest to calculate and communicate to employees. Corporate goals are set for each fiscal year, and people's score will always be the same as the result; what changes are the targets (discussed above) for each position. This method removes any individual differentiation of contribution to the result, but it ensures everyone has the same goal in mind.
100% individual results: each individual will have a different final attainment, whether based on projects, performance reviews, alignment with behaviors, etc. On the plus side, it differentiates the rewards of high performers from those of low performers. On the downside, this strategy can lead employees to stop pursuing a shared result (corporate goals like revenue, NPS, etc.), and it can also hurt collaboration between people, when helping someone else means moving further from your own individual goal.
Hybrid: many programs manage to put a part of both into operation, in either an additive or a multiplicative model.
Additive: The person has a scorecard made up of 70% individual goals and 30% corporate goals; if one of them comes out at zero, the person still receives part of the bonus.
Multiplicative: The person has individual results, and these are multiplied by the company's attainment. If either one comes out at zero, the person receives nothing.
This way, people pursue a shared company result and can at the same time be differentiated based on their individual contribution. On the downside, this program is complex to communicate and to teach employees, and it requires management systems that can measure results correctly.
Payment frequency
This is a “simpler” topic to design. Companies normally pay annually, in the year after the fiscal and evaluation year. Some pay semiannually, but that creates a second calculation process in the year, which for many HR teams can be too costly to go through twice a year.
Next steps
Once all these points are designed, it is important for the program to go through the board and the leadership one more time. The program's success is directly proportional to how much leadership believes in and trusts it. For example, a leader may consider the way the program evaluates “unfair” and, as a result, set “easy” goals to guarantee positive attainment and/or manipulate their team's evaluations so as not to “hurt them”.
Once leaders are on the same page, communication to the rest of the company should also get a high level of investment, making sure everyone understands how their total compensation has just increased significantly, instead of wondering how they could “lose” in the calculation process.