
Strategy
The dilemmas of CLT vs PJ compensation
Companies in Brazil have several formats for hiring professionals. In tech, the most common models are CLT (formal employment under Brazilian labor law) and PJ (contracting as a company). Each model has its advantages and disadvantages for both professionals and companies. That's why, in this article, we will focus on the nuances of…
Published Nov 21, 2022
Companies in Brazil have several ways of hiring professionals. In tech, the most common models are CLT (formal employment under Brazilian labor law) and PJ (contracting through the professional's own company). Each model has its advantages and disadvantages, for both professionals and companies. So in this article we focus on the nuances of these two ways of hiring in the context of technology companies.
The difference between PJ and CLT
A PJ (Pessoa Jurídica, a legal entity) is a legal entity separate from the individual, with its own CNPJ (company tax ID). That means that when a company hires a PJ, it is contracting services from another company.
For technology professionals, there are three common types: MEI (individual microentrepreneur), ME (microenterprise) and EPP (small business). These can be filed under the Simples Nacional, a unified tax regime.
The CLT (Consolidação das Leis Trabalhistas, the Brazilian labor code) was created to guarantee the rights and duties of an employee in a company. Since it was created in 1943, the CLT has been amended to adapt to the working landscape of Brazilians.
Under the CLT model, the employee has rights such as:
- Set weekly working hours and overtime pay;
- Minimum wage;
- Paid vacation days each year;
- 13th salary;
- Days off during the week;
- Contributions to social security and to the FGTS (Fundo de Garantia por Tempo de Serviço, the severance guarantee fund);
- Right to severance in case of dismissal;
- Other rights defined by the corresponding union.
Today, though, it is common to find companies that offer the same CLT benefits, or part of them, to PJs. These include legal benefits such as the 13th salary and paid vacation, as well as other benefits like health insurance, food and meal allowances, among others.
The table below gives a brief comparison of the two models:
| COMPARISON BETWEEN MODELS | ||
|---|---|---|
| PJ | CLT | |
| Tax charges | Taxes generally lower | Taxes generally higher |
| Management of tax responsibilities (paying taxes) | Responsibility of the PJ | Responsibility of the company |
| Benefits + 13th salary + paid vacation | Company is not required to provide | Mandatory for the company to provide (depending on the union) |
| Bonus | To be negotiated | Company policy |
| FGTS | No right to FGTS | Paid by the company, with no deduction from payroll |
| Working hours | Flexible | Controlled (up to 44 hours a week, depending on the union agreement) |
How do you compare a CLT and a PJ offer?
When comparing the two models, there are two important factors to weigh:
- Total compensation: that is, the full compensation package offered, including salary, benefits, bonus, vacation and the 13th salary.
- Flexibility of the work model: such as hours and days off.
To compare total compensation packages, you need to calculate the net amounts the professional will receive.
For a PJ in technology, taxes are usually calculated under the Simples Nacional, where a different rate applies depending on the type of service provided and revenue over the last 12 months. Technology professionals generally fall under Annex III or V.
With the invoice amount defined (the amount paid to the professional) and their Simples Nacional category, you can estimate the final net amount:
- Using the Simples Nacional table, the tax deduction on the invoice amount is calculated.
- From that amount, the pro-labore is set aside: the salary of the owner of the PJ company, that is, the professional. Its minimum follows the current minimum wage.
- The INSS (social security contribution) is then deducted from it (11% of the pro-labore, with a floor of 1 minimum wage and a ceiling equal to 6 minimum wages).
- Once the INSS is deducted, the IRPF (Imposto de Renda de Pessoa Física, individual income tax) is applied, with the pro-labore minus INSS as the base amount, which gives the net pro-labore.
- The monthly net amount the PJ receives in this case is the net invoice amount, minus the pro-labore, plus the net pro-labore.
- The annual net amount is then the monthly amount multiplied by 12 (the number of months).
Note that a few precautions apply to this calculation:
- To define the Simples Nacional rate, we need to use revenue from the last 12 months. In this simplified scenario, the invoice amount is assumed to have stayed the same over the 12 months before the calculation.
- The pro-labore should be chosen so that it equals the salary of a professional doing the same type of work. In addition, the IRPF deducted from the pro-labore can vary with the number of dependents.
- The annex the PJ falls under should reflect the category of services provided and has a big impact on tax deductions.
For an employee under the CLT model, taxation also varies with annual income, but follows a different INSS table and a different Receita Federal (tax authority) table.
- Given the gross base salary, charges are deducted, usually already withheld through payroll:
- The INSS is calculated from a Federal Government table, progressively. This amount is deducted from the gross salary. Note that for a CLT employee, the INSS amount has neither a floor nor a ceiling.
- From the salary after the INSS deduction, the IRRF (Imposto de Renda Retido na Fonte, income tax withheld at source) is deducted, very similar to the IRPF calculation on a PJ's pro-labore.
- The monthly net salary under the CLT model is the gross amount after the INSS deduction followed by the IRRF.
- For a CLT employee, the annual net salary is calculated by multiplying the monthly net amount by 13.3, which covers the 12 months of work, the 13th salary and ⅓ vacation bonus. This amount can also include benefits received (health insurance, meal and food vouchers, etc.) and the bonus.
- Benefits: tax-exempt for the employee.
- Bonus: 22% deduction for IRRF.
Here too, you need to consider some possible variations in the calculation:
- Depending on the number of dependents, the IRRF amount can vary, with an additional deduction per dependent.
- With the rise of remote work, the Vale Transporte (VT, commuting allowance), a benefit that used to be mandatory with a payroll deduction, now applies only when the employee actually commutes. Since the vast majority of startup professionals work remotely or in a hybrid setup, VT was not included in the calculations.
With the net amounts received under both models calculated, you can work out the total annual package (the total compensation). Note that, depending on the agreement between the professional and the company, the PJ's total package may include the value of benefits, vacation and the 13th salary, which are mandatory for a CLT contract. Some also include in the CLT total compensation the value of the FGTS, which is not deducted from the salary but is paid directly by the company and equals 8% of the base salary.
The second aspect to consider is the work model itself, which tends to be more flexible under PJ. Even though some companies offer flexible hours to a CLT employee, some professionals prefer to keep a PJ contract to, for example, reduce the agreed weekly hours and so be able to run another project in parallel (always remembering that, depending on the contract, the PJ may owe the company exclusivity).
Calculation example
For this example, let's suppose a recruiter is going to make an offer to a candidate under the CLT model with a compensation package already defined. But the candidate prefers a PJ model. How do you know which PJ offer would be equivalent to the CLT offer?
Let's consider the following compensation package under CLT:
- Monthly base salary: R$ 20,000.00
- Monthly benefits: R$ 1,500.00
- Annual bonus: 3 x base salary (R$ 60,000.00)
In this scenario, we have:
| Monthly salary | |
|---|---|
| INSS deduction | R$ 828.39 |
| IRRF deduction | R$ 4,403.19 |
| Net monthly salary | R$ 14,768.42 |
| Net monthly salary + benefits | R$ 16,268.42 |
| Annual salary | |
| Vacation (gross) | R$ 6,666.67 |
| Vacation (net) | R$ 4,922.81 |
| 13th salary (gross) | R$ 20,000.00 |
| 13th salary (net) | R$ 14,768.42 |
| Bonus (gross) | R$ 60,000.00 |
| Bonus (net) | R$ 46,800.00 |
| Annual benefits | R$ 18,000.00 |
| Net annual salary | R$ 243,712.23 |
| Net annual salary + benefits | R$ 261,712.23 |
So, under a CLT contract, an employee with this compensation package would earn R$ 14,768.42 a month (R$ 16,268.42 counting benefits). If we consider a full year for that same employee at the company, with the right to vacation, the 13th salary and the bonus, the net annual package is R$ 243,712.23 (R$ 261,712.23 including benefits).
Using our calculator, you can get the PJ contract value (that is, the PJ's invoice amount) whose net value equals the CLT's net annual compensation package.
Let's assume that, in this case, the PJ will not get a 13th salary, vacation, bonus or benefits. We also assume the PJ will be under Annex V of the Simples Nacional and the pro-labore will be 30% of the invoice amount. That gives a PJ invoice amount of R$ 28,671.88, which produces an annual compensation package equivalent to the CLT package (within 0.1%). The detailed result is shown in the table below:
| Monthly salary | |
|---|---|
| Invoice amount | R$ 28,671.88 |
| Simples Nacional (Annex V) deduction | R$ 4,785.94 |
| Pro-labore | R$ 8,601.56 |
| INSS deduction | R$ 799.92 |
| IRPF deduction | R$ 1,276.45 |
| Net pro-labore | R$ 6,525.19 |
| Net monthly amount | R$ 21,809.57 |
| Annual salary | |
| Net annual salary | R$ 261,714.84 |
So, which hiring model is best?
This is a question many companies and professionals ask, and the answer depends on the situation of both parties.
The PJ model can be cheaper for the company, since its cost is exactly the invoice amount, and more advantageous tax-wise for the professional, thanks to lower charges. In addition, small companies, such as early-stage startups, can benefit from hiring PJs because it requires less operational management from HR, such as handling payroll, benefits and vacation.
However, you need to make sure the relationship between the PJ and the hiring company does not legally resemble a CLT arrangement, which could lead to lawsuits or tax penalties. That is why it is necessary to respect the requirements set by law.
As the company grows and there are more interactions that can establish an employment relationship, the CLT model becomes more attractive, since there is an HR operation to manage all the obligations as an employer. This way, even with a higher cost per employee (compared with a PJ at the same base salary, the CLT model costs on average twice as much), the risk of labor lawsuits is reduced. The right time to move all contracts to CLT varies with each company's strategy, but it is well known that technology companies, because they accept more risk in general, tend to make this transition later.
When moving from PJ to CLT, you need to consider the impact on the employee's net salary, and additional benefits can help soften that impact.
Some companies try to keep the same net salary the employee received as a PJ when converting to CLT. This practice, besides being more attractive from the employee's point of view, costs the company more than the standard conversion (twice the base salary). That is because on top of the tax burden on salary and all labor payments, there are also benefit costs.
For that reason, the right moment to move from PJ to CLT should take into account not only the company's maturity stage but also its financial liquidity.