
Equity
Why are ESOPs or Stock Option Programs less attractive in Brazil today?
This year we lived through a very new reality in the world of VCs and Startups. The volume of investment fell; high interest rates contributed to some valuation corrections; the pressure for efficiency at startups grew much larger, and so we entered a moment of uncertainty…
Published Nov 25, 2022
This year we are living in a very new reality in the world of VCs and startups. Investment volume has dropped; high interest rates have contributed to some valuation corrections; the pressure for efficiency at startups has grown much greater, and as a result, employees have entered a moment of uncertainty about the company's future / success.
It would be obvious to say that this new reality directly affected equity programs, known as Stock Options. After all, the survival of many startups depends on their ability to attract future investment, grow and, as a consequence, increase the value of their shares. But the story is not that simple…
First of all, do you know what Stock Options are? Well, most people don't.
Stock Options (options to buy shares) are a type of compensation program, classified as Long-Term Incentive, that many startups create and offer to employees as a way to engage people, build a sense of belonging, share the inherent risk of the business and keep talent for longer.
Many startups use this tool to attract professionals who believe in the company's future, and also to recognize the people who show commitment to the startup's success. After all, the Stock Option model starts from the premise that:
If talent makes the startup grow and the founders raise larger investments > the startup will gain value > the share price will go up > people will get a bigger financial return when they sell their shares
So how does it work?
As the name says, stock options, or options to buy shares, represent a right given by the company so that employees can acquire or buy a certain number of the organization's shares at a pre-set price (known as the Strike Price).
That's right: when you are granted stock options at the company, they only turn into actual shares (and you into a shareholder) if you choose to exercise your right to buy (and pay the price agreed in the contract). From the moment you exercise and buy those shares, you can sell them when a liquidity event happens.
And when can I exercise my shares?
Most stock option plans have a vesting period. It tells you how long you must stay at the company before you can exercise them.
The most common market standard is a total vesting of 4 years, with an initial 1-year waiting period (better known as the "cliff"). After the first year, the shares usually vest every month or quarter, until the full 4 years are complete.
People only need to exercise their shares when they actually go to sell them, or if you, as an employee, decide to leave the company before a liquidity event happens.
A Stock Option program only needs to be declared on your income tax return when the person exercises their shares, that is, when what is in the contract becomes reality. Using legal support to bring clarity to this topic for employees is extremely important.
What are the possible liquidity events? When can it turn into money?
From the moment you exercise your Stock Options and they become actual shares, you can make money by selling them for a price higher than the exercise price. This can happen in different ways:
- Acquisition of the company by another organization;
- A new funding round;
- The company going public on the stock exchange (IPO);
- Direct sale of your shares to another interested person
In short…
Stock Options = Option to buy shares
Strike Price = Price set in the Stock Options contract when you receive the package from the company
Vesting = Period you must stay at the company to be able to exercise the shares and actually become an owner
Liquidity event = situations the company goes through in which you can sell your exercised shares
Let's look at an example to make it clearer:
A person was hired by a Fintech that is just starting out in the market, and at hiring received a Stock Options package of 5,000 shares at a set price (strike price) of USD 5.00 / share.
The startup's vesting covers a total period of 4 years, with a cliff in the first year, and after the first year the shares "vest" every month.
After 10 years, the startup went through several funding rounds and reached an IPO, and the share price at that moment was USD 50.00 / share
How do we calculate this person's financial gain?
5,000 shares x USD 5.00 = USD 25,000 (the amount the hired person will have to pay to be entitled to the shares)
5,000 shares x USD 50.00 - USD 25,000 = USD 225,000 (the gross amount the hired person will get back from selling the shares)
How is the size of the share pool set aside to recognize / attract talent defined?
This is a very important decision and it should be made between the founders and the startup's board. It is important to think about how many shares each person will get and how many people we want to incentivize through a program like this, especially considering that competition for talent among startups only keeps growing and we need to use many tools to attract and retain the best.
Every startup has its own reality, but what we currently see in the market is that for companies in the early stage of operation (Seed / Series A), 10-15% of the total pool is allocated to distribute to talent (both in recruiting and in recognition). We recommend reviewing this percentage at every funding round or when planning to hire for new positions.
But should Stock Options be a compensation program for everyone at the company? How do we best define this criterion?
It is important to say that there is no right and wrong, only market best practices that change very quickly, given the dynamic context of startups. There are three main points to consider:
- What the founders' culture is on the topic of Stock Options, what they fundamentally believe
- How many shares are available in the pool and how predictable the next rounds are
- What stage the startup is in. Startups in the early stage of operation use stock options more to attract talent, since the share price is still very low and people will be more open to risk and to building together.
- How much impact each person / position has on the company's success.
- How much each person values the Stock Options program.
Conclusion:
Stock Options are still a widely used attraction and recognition program among startups, and they hold enormous appeal for people who believe in the company's long term. As a compensation tool, they make a lot of sense for startups, since they help keep the company financially healthier as it grows, and can create a shared sense of success among people.
However… we have some problems and complexities in keeping this program engaging:
- It is not a simple program to understand. And it is clear that the effort startups need to put into explaining and then engaging people about this program is huge. Yet that is often not what happens. In fact, we spend very little time and energy explaining the nuances of this program, and we can still be much more transparent.
- The startup world boomed. 10 years ago it was easier to convince someone to leave the more traditional world and take on the risk of working at a startup, believing in the long-term financial return. Today the competition for talent is among startups, and it is even harder when we talk about competing with Tech companies that have already walked the path to success (for example, Nubank)
- Unfortunately, in Brazil we have few examples of startups that delivered a significant financial return to employees. That doesn't help founders make the Stock Options program tangible and raise people's trust.
- Any swing in the market or shift in the VC economic context hurts the program's credibility a lot. Stock Optionscan be a lot of money, or they can be nothing. And in the current Brazilian context, with our historical and economic baggage, it is very hard to sustain engagement around something so uncertain.
What can the founder do?
-
COMMUNICATE, COMMUNICATE, COMMUNICATE. Explain to people why Stock Options matter, how they connect to the company's culture and what value proposition the person is buying into when joining your startup. Make sure people understand the program and its future financial potential. Provide materials with explained content, especially on the most technical elements that people know little about. Create moments to talk with people about the subject. At every funding round, show openly how each person's equity is evolving.
-
Benchmark against other startups and understand how total compensation is being put together, both at companies at similar stages and at somewhat more advanced ones.
-
Create a Stock Options program with clearer criteria: define which levels in the company will be eligible to take part and assign a number of shares or a range per level, considering both recruiting and engagement. Think about who is really committed to your startup's long term. Stock Options won't make people stay, but those who stay because they like the company, its culture and its management style will be happier to be recognized with a program like this.
-
At every funding round or fundraising moment, look for opportunities for people to sell part of their shares, even a small part. A sense of achievement over time is very important for people to make success tangible and trust in the company's success
Stay informed:
- Changes in labor rules: as reported this November by Brazil Journal, a potential change is about to happen, with a higher body of the Administrative Council of Tax Appeals (Carf) voting to remove the charge of social security contributions on stock option plans, which could favor startups' Stock Options programs by reducing the labor-risk exposure of this model.
- More content on Stock Options and long-term compensation models: if you want to understand this topic in more detail, check the content built by equity management platforms such as Basementand Carta