
Article
Why you should think carefully about your compensation strategy
The standard model for developing a compensation strategy has three parts: start with the business strategy to inform the talent strategy, then fold both into the compensation strategy. The model is intuitive and hard to argue with, but putting compensation in that third spot also dilutes the effort most companies put into thinking about how they should pay people.
Published Apr 11, 2023
The standard model for developing a compensation strategy has three parts: start with the business strategy to inform the talent strategy, then fold both into the compensation strategy. The model is intuitive and hard to argue with, but putting compensation in that third spot also dilutes the effort most companies put into thinking about how they should pay people. That is a mistake.
A company may have a well-defined business strategy, yet it often puts less effort into a somewhat more generic talent strategy ("We only hire 'A' players!") and an even less focused compensation strategy. Consider the following statement, which can be found, with minor variations, at almost every publicly traded company:
"Our philosophy is to offer competitive compensation so that we can attract, retain and motivate the talent we need to reach our goals."
Can we really call that a strategy, or even a compensation philosophy? Would we accept that level of generality in how we communicate our business strategy, our value proposition? Of course not, because our companies would quickly shut down after failing to make clear to customers why they exist. So could your company be losing the talent it needs most because it did not hire that talent carefully, by defining and communicating its policies well?
From a strategic standpoint, there seems to be some merit in not standing out because of off-market pay. No company wants to start an expensive arms race with other players, so there is every incentive not to be bold and to do what everyone else is doing. As a result, many compensation teams run their annual market analyses to find the new market median for their base salary, bonus and equity plans. Then they send the budget bill to finance, outsourcing whatever strategic thinking they have to the survey results. What a waste of our potential! We do not serve our companies or our people well when we fail to recognize the impact of a careful compensation strategy, not only on the company's results but also on our people's livelihoods. Compensation strategy matters, but it is hard to know where to start.
Let's begin with the end in mind. The outcome of a compensation strategy is to help decide what the company will pay for, to whom and why. The amount of money available to pay people is not infinite, even for large, well-funded companies, so the company that makes the best pay choices, most consistently, has an advantage over its undisciplined peers. To make good compensation decisions, the company needs a principled infrastructure (a compensation strategy) that defines how it will say yes, no and not yet to paying the right people, the right amounts, in the right formats and at the right time (a smart compensation strategy cares about the "no" and the "not yet" as much as the "yes").
Identifying what is "right" depends on the talent strategy and the business. Consider two kinds of companies: the first is focused on solving very hard problems, like creating entirely new market categories or approaching an existing industry in a fundamentally different way. That can take years to deliver results and requires a lot of capital to absorb the inevitable mistakes, doubts and root causes. The second kind is focused on winning now, with only one chance to avoid extinction by faster peers. The two companies have to pay differently, because they have different reasons to exist, need different types of people and have a different time horizon for showing results.
The first company needs a "band" willing to stay together even without an obvious road map to riches or glory (they will figure it out together). Its compensation strategy should therefore focus on the long term, which tactically makes equity and/or long-term performance the right place to invest its limited resources (and the prize has to be very large to justify the wait). For the second company, the business plan is set and the mercenary model of talent is acceptable. A strong emphasis on frequent cash (through raises and bonuses) is expected, because you need it to deliver results immediately.
These are extreme examples, and most companies will fall somewhere in the middle. That makes thinking through your compensation strategy even more essential to stand out with the candidates you want to attract, retain and motivate. This does not mean your compensation strategy has to be fundamentally unique or especially clever; the best goals are clarity, consistency and fairness. People should know what to expect when they self-select into your company, because if they don't, you will soon be replacing them, and that is expensive both financially and culturally. This is especially true for new executives, who will join with their own compensation model and the expectation of rewarding people the same way that made them successful in the past. A thoughtful, clearly articulated compensation strategy, proven over time, will set the right tone from the start and keep large parts of the company from drifting out of alignment.
Perhaps the most important reason to think hard about your compensation strategy is that a bad strategy cannot be undone quickly. Unlike most internal company strategies (the marketing plan, the product roadmap or the DE&I model), there is usually no on/off switch for flaws in compensation strategy. The decisions you make about pay will leave a residue across the company for a long time, in the form of higher payroll costs, market reputation and pay inequities. The need for a better kind of compensation strategy is urgent, but it is not easy.
Want help starting this move at your company? Book a chat with Zivo hereand get a diagnosis of your compensation strategy.